Skip to main content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Open Educational Resources (OER): Evaluate

Using OER: Benefits and challenges

 

Benefits Challenges
  • Expanded access to knowledge
  • More affordable education
  • Elimination of unnecessary duplication of effort
  • Free sharing
  • Easy distribution 
  • Flexible customization
  • Opportunities for collaboration, creativity, and innovation        
  • Greater diversity of teaching and learning environments
  • Facilitation of independent, self-directed study
  • Uneven quality
  • Localization challenges
  • Sustainability concerns
  • Irregular updating
  • Copyright clearance barriers
  • May be costly to produce
  • Accessibility issues
  • Discovery problems
  • Limited OER in some subject areas                          
  • Limited language options

 

Traditional evaluation criteria

Content quality

  • Content is accurate
  • Pedagogical methods are sound
  • Reputation of author/ institution is transparent 
  • Peer review available or used
  • Sources are identified and cited 

Pedagogical appropriateness

  • Alignment with a learning outcome or course objective
  • Appropriate reading/ domain level for your students

(reused and adapted from Sarah Crissinger, CC BY NC SA)

Additional evaluation criteria

Licensing status

  • Clear licensing declaration 
  • Allows for reuse, re-purposing or refinement

Technical quality

  • High technical quality (clear visuals, high production value)
  • Platform compatibility (viewable and usable on both MAC's and PC's)
  • Platform currency
  • Accessible to people with disabilities
  • Accessible to people using older computers 

OER evaluation rubrics and checklists