Skip to Main Content

POSC 413

Library resources supporting assignments in International Political Economy.

Authority is Constructed and Contextual

There is no single way to evaluate a source for reliability or appropriateness. Instead, we must ask many questions of each source. Below are some ways we can look at a source to evaluate it.

"Information resources reflect their creators’ expertise and credibility, and are evaluated based on the information need and the context in which the information will be used." 1 Framework

Whether something is important or can be viewed as an authority depends on the situation you plan to use it in. A tweet about a political policy isn't generally something we would cite. But if the president is the one tweeting it, how does that change the context? A famous speaker might lend authority to a particular management technique, but if they are trying to sell you training materials on that technique from a company they own, does that change our trust in their authority on the topic? If a peer-reviewed article uses an experiment to support its hypothesis, but the experiment was funded by a corporation with a conflicting interest, does that change how reliable we think it might be?